The RationalistSkip to content


We have registered
199.103.200 visits
There are 7364 articles   written by 1065 authors. They could occupy 29017 A4 pages

Search in sites:

Advanced search..

The latest sites..
Digests archive....

 How do you like that?
This rocks!
Well done
I don't mind
This sucks
  

Casted 2991 votes.
Chcesz wiedzieć więcej?
Zamów dobrą książkę.
Propozycje Racjonalisty:
Comments to article Seven Mistakes of the Messiah

Enter your comment on this article …
Steve - The Seven Mistakes of Jesus
I intend nothing but to bring some ideas to your attention. The latter six points or "mistakes of Jesus" are all depending on the reality of the first. By this, I mean that if the first were correct then the others would have to be reevaluated concerning each their own truth.
Your argument against the existence of God is thus, "But when we consider the pointlessness of a violent universe, plus parasites causing serious diseases in man and beast, plus the pain inflicted on sensitive creatures by Mother Nature, we can but conclude that there is no Almighty Abba." This argument, as we both know, is called The Problem of Evil. Most people point to the wickedness of man and say there can be no God. This argument is a lack of responsibility on the hands of mankind. Even your own editor, Kaz Dziamka, agrees with this point as he says, " Like Huxley, I would like to submit that indeed about two thirds of all human misery is human made and thus avoidable; but, unlike Huxley, I don't think it can be eliminated through a Huxleyan blend of Oriental mysticism and Western science. I submit that most of our problems can be solved through a practical, pragmatic and operational philosophy of life known as rationalism which does include science but rejects mysticism and all kinds of religious and other superstition." (Kaz Dziamka, Editor: The American Rationalist) The third part of "human misery"(Dziamka), that Dziamka does not mention, is the part which you now refer. This part is that of natural evils.
Natural evils can be catagorized into two classes. The first class is that which I call "natural evil by location". Examples of this are situations such as landslides, forest fires, and the like that effect human life. The fact is, in the event of a landslide, that there is nothing intrinsically evil in the landslide itself, the evil is that it effected and possible even killed humans. The event of the landslide would be morally neutral had it not effected humans in a negative way. There can be no blame in this situation, even if people are injured and/or killed, because the slide would have happened regardless of whether people were there or not. If one wanted to put blame somewhere it would have to be on the people for building houses on or near the base of an unstable hill. It is likewise that those who choose to live on a tropical island for the beauty of the area must recognize and take responsibility for their choice in moving to an area known for hurricane activity.
The second class of natural evils are what I call "natural evil by self-affliction". Examples of these types of evils are disease, famine, and the like. These evils are perceived as natural but are actually natural event caused, again, by man. For example, a once fertile land becomes a dry wasteland and the inhabitants die of thirst and hunger. It appears that this event just happened, there seems to be no direct cause. The choices that man has made concerning technology and industrialization have effected the climate and resources of every area inhabited by mankind. If one were to inspect the area with a biological and scientific eye he would find pollution in the water, chemicals in the air, and a temperature not natural to the area due to global warming or the depletion of the ozone layer, which is caused by carbon monoxide and several other man made gasses. Man is quick to feed himself, warm himself, and reside in materials that he does not completely understand. Often, people drink common tap water without thinking what is in it. People also smoke cigarettes and then later question why they got cancer. Man has exposed natural diseases to unnatural conditions and caused them to mutate and into new and more complex diseases. These evils are in nature, but only due to man's influence.
If you are questioning why diseases exist at all, then there is an entire new argument to have. This argument, the argument of best possible worlds, would take further discussion. To ask why diseases exist at all, is the same as if to ask why flowers exist. One would say that the flowers are good and it is acceptable that they exist, but diseases are not beneficial to man or other forms of life and therefore should not exist. If one does not believe in God then they cannot say this. If God does not exist then man is just another animal, a rational animal, and who are we then to judge which other animals, that are equal in existence to ourselves, should have the privilege to live. If God does exist, then, who are we to question the choice of an infinite being.
Another approach I would like to examine is one that belongs to your beloved David Hume. In section four of Hume's "An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding" Hume states, "The contrary of every matter of fact is still possible; because it can never imply a contradiction, and is conceived by the mind with the same facility and distinctness, as if ever so conformable to reality." What this means in terms of God is that God either exists or He does not, this is a fact. If you wan to claim that God does not exist you must accept that the opposite is at least possible.
In retrospect, now with at least the possibility of God, the first point on your list of mistakes made by Jesus is possibly wrong. If this point is wrong then there is a possibility that the other six are wrong as well. This is possible considering the fact that they were all based off the assumption that the first point was correct. Now, what the implications of this are to you are up to you.
Thank You,
Steve
Author: Steve Date: 10-10-2004
Reklama
mikolaj - comment to the article
If this what i've just read is a point of view generous for the poeople who don's believe in God and Scripture, there is no additional argument for me needed that atheism and sceptisism are based not only on the logical arguments but also on a strong faith. Atheists are not the ones who doesn't believe in nothing. They believe in themselves, and their infallibility. Hello to the "rationalists"!
Author: mikolaj Date: 13-09-2005
michal - Steve - congratulations!
After reading the article and the comments I must admit that it was much more interesting to go through Steve's comment rather than "Seven Mistakes...". And although I think that arguments used by A.J Mattill were pathetic in many points, I cannot agree with Mikołaj's opinion. Fortunately, plenty of rationalists are not people who try to prove that Bible is just another kind of fairy tale. They (including me) believe in scientific evidence of actions and processes and try to explain world in a rational way. Which always (or at least often) means questioning the existence of God (god or gods). Thus, agnosticism is much closer to my state of mind than atheism. I can't exclude the possibility of existence of any supernatural power or The Creator, it is that I do not believe in any of the holy books such as Bible, Quran or The Vedas.
Regards,
Michal
Author: michal Date: 06-03-2007
mike34 - Mike34
God always exists and enlightens us, I always believe in God uno-online.co/
Author: mike34  Date: 30-06-2023
dansonpas
I will never doubt that God is real and that he can illuminate our lives; I have faith in God. basketball-stars.co/
Author: dansonpas  Date: 05-07-2023
drewbinsky
I always put my faith in God ovo-game.com
Author: drewbinsky  Date: 11-07-2023
lilycollins34 - incredibox
The Problem of Evil is a philosophical challenge that questions the coexistence of an all-powerful, incrediboxgame.co all-knowing, and benevolent God with the existence of evil and suffering in the world. It has been a significant point of contention for those who believe in the existence of God and seek to reconcile the concept of a loving and powerful deity with the existence of suffering and natural disasters.
Author: lilycollins34  Date: 25-07-2023
Emma.123456
I really like your idea. Although there are still many mixed opinions, I believe that this idea will be of great help to everyone. mapquestdirections.org
Author: Emma.123456  Date: 02-08-2023
zealoie - 1235
Whether you're a seasoned outdoors 2048cupcakes.io/ enthusiast or someone looking for a reliable tool for everyday tasks, the KaBar 1183 Blade is undoubtedly worth considering.
Author: zealoie  Date: 08-08-2023
melonplay
The Problem of Evil, bloxdio.io as you've mentioned, is a philosophical dilemma that questions the compatibility of the existence of an all-powerful, all-knowing, and benevolent God with the presence of evil and suffering in the world.
Author: melonplay  Date: 08-08-2023
kaabir01 - Service Provider
All you need is the brilliant help of Delhi Escort Services and we honestly bolster you. Inasmuch as you keep the right conduct, you’ll have significant pleasurable time at last. www.priyankasinghania.com/ You’ll like our Agency when you get yourself alone at the tip of the night. In any case,
Author: kaabir01  Date: 19-10-2023
ESVEL]5U6Z+x,++hu
Most players are not very patient when they play this game for the first time, which usually lasts for a few minutes. The three essential skills in Geometry Dash Lite are time, patience, and memorization. If you're able to manage everything, you'll quickly become an expert! geometrydashlite.co
Author: ESVEL]5U6Z+x,++hu  Date: 20-10-2023
Zxcv@54321 - Delhi Call Girls
These are high up girls from outside cities of the country, foreign nations and from posh areas of the capital. www.poojaroy.com/ These girls are the talk of the town due to their beauty, elegance and class and are most admired babies by VIP and VVIP clients.
Author: Zxcv@54321  Date: 21-10-2023
Zxcv@54321 - Delhi Escorts Service
We have a group of stunning women at Delhi Escorts Service kajalahuja.com/ who embrace all body types and are prepared to take away all of your worries and make you feel at ease.
Author: Zxcv@54321  Date: 21-10-2023
preetiroy - preeti
There is no doubt that numerous Escort agencies are there in Delhi Escorts. But, if we talk about the Delhi Escorts associated with our Escort agency, they are very talented and highly rated. www.escortsdelhicallgirls.com We possess a great collection of Escorts who are very professional to have enough experience in providing effective Escort services to Macho and lusty men like you.
Author: preetiroy  Date: 23-10-2023
johnbabu - johnbabu
Do you desire to meet with an elite and charming lady tonight? We can hear you. www.khalifa-escorts.com/delhi-call-girls.html Our Delhi escort agency is taking all possible steps to meet the requirement of customers. We have recruited a variety of female escorts in Delhi to deliver services. No corner is left out of our quality Delhi escort services. It means our horny females can come to meet in luxurious hotels, residences, apartments, and restaurants situated in Delhi.
Author: johnbabu  Date: 06-11-2023
satyam - Escorts in Mandi Hills
Indian girls are among the most attractive in India. This is a fact that you can easily find in any search engine. www.nargis-khan.com/mandi-hills-escorts.html In our Mandi Hills Call Girls service, girls get recruited based on their ability and field of interest. You can trust that the girl you choose will be your friend and make your dreams come true. Our Mandi Hills Call Girls girls are beautiful and perfect and honest and will give you genuine love and satisfaction.
Author: satyam  Date: 10-11-2023
Zxcv@54321 - Call Girls in Muzaffarnagar
We know that you must have dreamt of having naughty things, www.ektachopra.com/muzaffarnagar-escorts.html and we can help you find the same model in Call Girls in Muzaffarnagar to make your day special with her. You can enjoy yourself with her, and she will bring out your dark fantasies by making you more aroused and sensitive.
Author: Zxcv@54321  Date: 24-11-2023
iampriyanka - service provider
Highly qualified call girls won't disappoint you at any cost because it might mark negative on their personality. www.julieoberoi.com/bicholim-call-girls.html If you want someone who could give you whole independence while spending time in her arms so you better choose Independent Call Girls.
Author: iampriyanka  Date: 04-12-2023
shweta - service provider
These are the ones who are free birds and social butterflies. They love to go out of town and party unlimited. Unlike the wild ones at the www.shwetamalik.in/bhopal-call-girls.html agency these are the ones who will actually show you how's a party is done or how to party hard. These girls are the life of a party and will show you how to party.
Author: shweta  Date: 05-12-2023
satyam - massage service
One must visit red-light districts, or “strip joints,” which can be found in many cities nowadays. These districts were once a common place for men to meet and have conversations with Escorts. www.delhibeauti(*)m/chanakyapuri-call-girls.html These days, you can schedule an appointment with a Chanakyapuri Call Girl Service with only the press of a button, thanks to the proliferation of apps and websites that make it easy to do so. To make the right decision, it’s crucial to have crystal-clear information.
Author: satyam  Date: 13-12-2023
kunaal - Chanakyapuri Escorts
No.1 escort girls in Chanakyapuri, you will get to enjoy a wild and intimate night, full of passionate activities. Our escorts in Chanakyapuri will make sure that you are fulfilled to your fullest satisfaction. www.thedelhiesc(*)n/chanakyapuri-call-girls.html We have a wide range of escorts, from college going girls, to Indian, to Asian, to European, to American, to African and much more.
Author: kunaal  Date: 22-12-2023
prince123 - Delhi Escorts
In this www.independentescortsinnewdelhi.org/, safety is very important. Most of the people who belong to reputed families and society and are well-established in their professional terms want to hire this sexiest escort girl service here.So, they always prefer such fantasy and pleasurable services in a safe mode.They don’t want to get any legal compliances or they want to avail this service hidden.
Author: prince123  Date: 26-12-2023
johnbabu - johnbabu
We are a premier Escort service provider in South Ex. Clients come to us for many good reasons. We can easily provide a dream www.eliteescort.co.in/south-ex-escorts.html to clients. The irresistible Escorts in South Ex play their roles in entertaining customers perfectly. As a result, you can expect total satisfaction in the session. Even our South Ex Escort services are designed to deliver unforgettable moments to customers.
Author: johnbabu  Date: 05-01-2024
timothyferriss
The retrobowl-game.co is the ideal contest for the couch quarterback to make their case. The game, which is presented in a gorgeous retro aesthetic, offers straightforward roster management, including press responsibilities and the handling of fragile egos, while you get to make decisions on the field.
Author: timothyferriss  Date: 09-01-2024
Andree Oren
Grabbing your device and preparing to merge isn't just a call to action; it's an invitation to a world where each decision matters, and every move takes you one step closer to watermelon supremacy. watermelongame.io
Author: Andree Oren  Date: 11-01-2024
herrylauu
One of the most exciting aspects of asmall-worldcup.com is its regular global tournaments. These events bring together the best players and teams from around the world, creating an atmosphere of intense competition and sportsmanship.
Author: herrylauu  Date: 15-01-2024
kunaal - New Delhi Escorts
Escorts in Delhi from Thedelhi can be hired for any event or special occasion; you can even book her for several days. Their rates are very affordable, making their services easily affordable. www.erosescorts.in/ In addition, these girls provide services, including sex and foreplay. Furthermore, their laughter will help alleviate tension. Besides sex services alone, these highly educated call girl Delhi offer other assistance, like managing work-related problems as they come up.
Author: kunaal  Date: 10-02-2024
Manisha - Service Provider
You all are thinking about why we cover all the faces of our escorts. We just wanna tell you that it is our privacy that we can not reveal our escort profiles as soon you book. www.manisharani.in/ Our Escorts also belong to a family or professional background. So Nowadays, Peoples are doing wrong with their photos. Please do not do this. We extremely request you. Do not take miss use our photographs. When you have taken the services please try to hide the things as we are hiding for all. Our Strict policy we can not share any kind of personal details of the clients. So just think a little about our VIP Goa Escorts Service.
Author: Manisha  Date: 12-02-2024
prince123 - Delhi Escorts
Most gentlemen prefer escort services because they need companionship and casual short-term relations.Some men may seek emotional connection and i
Author: prince123  Date: 14-02-2024
Epcj6Bb4$p#DTry
It discusses how human actions can contribute to what are perceived as natural evils and raises questions about responsibility and judgment in the face of such phenomena. The mention of David Hume's perspective adds another layer to the discussion on the existence of God. Overall, the text presents thought-provoking ideas that prompt reflection on the nature of suffering, human agency, and the concept of divine intervention. mylocationnow.io/
Author: Epcj6Bb4$p#DTry  Date: 21-02-2024

Sort comments from the newest

Sign in to add comment

  

Sign in using Facebook or OpenID
In case not signed in - sign up..

Advertisement
[ Cooperation ] [ Advertise ] [ Map of the site ] [ F.A.Q. ] [ Store ] [ Sign up ] [ Contact ]
The Rationalist © Copyright 2000-2018 (English section of Polish Racjonalista.pl)
The Polish Association of Rationalists (PSR)